This tale was excerpted from Mandy Bell Guardians Beat e-newsletter. To review the complete e-newsletter, go here. And subscribe to obtain it regularly in your a lot of the Guardians' offseason boils down to one inquiry: Will they trade Shane Bieber? This will certainly be the speaking factor relating to the organization till they make that choice. Yet what feels like a simple yes or no solution suddenly becomes a domino effect of even more head-scratching scenarios. Allow's start with Bieber. There's no other way to understand if he'll be traded. The Guardians will unquestionably be paying attention to any kind of and all telephone calls concerning the right-handed ace's situation. And also, they require offensive aid, and the simplest way to make a trade for a bat is to remove from a location of stamina. Thanks to the strong rookie efficiencies from Tanner Bibee, Gavin Williams and Logan Allen, the Guardians' rotation is as soon as again poised to flourish. So, even without Cal Quantrill, who was marked for project and traded to Colorado, dealing a bottle like Bieber might be the simplest step. And hence starts the cause and effect. If trading Bieber is the plan, what can the Guardians get for him? The stars seemed to be lined up for the 2020 AL Cy Youthful victor to be relocated at this year's Profession Target date https://www.guardiansshorts.com. At that factor, he had one-and-a-half years of control left, and he can have been a target for any kind of contending group looking for beginning throwing. Rather, he was sidelined to start the 2nd fifty percent of the season with best elbow joint swelling. He really did not go back to the big league rubber till completion of September for 2 his last trip, he appeared like classic Bieber, enabling one run on 5 hits in 6 innings. But that was simply a couple of starts after two months on the damaged listing. His hidden numbers have been indicating that the success he saw in 2020 could be tough to duplicate, and his velocity has dipped over the last few years. Add that to the uncertainty of what the elbow joint problems from this past period might indicate in the future, and now we have our next inquiry. What's Bieber's trade worth? In theory, he's still one of the most effective beginning bottles on the marketplace. Yet these aspects can trigger opposing clubs to be reluctant in offering up the sort of skill Cleveland would be trying to find in exchange for a starter that might have some enigma. The Guardians hardly ever make any profession for a penny less than they believe they deserve. Yet they additionally aren't ones to enjoy gifted starters walk into free firm without anything in return. If the Guardians can locate the perfect trade companion, there's nothing quiting them from moving Bieber for an impact bat. If they can not, they can additionally cross their fingers and wish that Bieber has a strong first fifty percent of the 2024 season and aim to trade him to a competing group at following year's Due date. Yet what takes place if they do not trade him this winter months? Exactly how do they enhance the offense?No one is ever entirely off the table when it involves trade talks in Cleveland. However, Andrs Gimnez and Josh Naylor likely aren't going anywhere, and Emmanuel Clase need to be back in the closing function. From there, anything might be a possibility. The Guardians have lots of mid-tier outfielders that are overcrowding those settings, but that wouldn't motivate the type of return required to take this offense to the next level. Depending upon that the company is trying to trade for, possibly Cleveland would want to get rid of various other top pitching talent, a very concerned prospect or placement players who have actually served in crucial roles over the last period or 2. However all of that is established by what the Guardians can obtain in return. The No. 1 thing Cleveland requires to do is develop a strategy. If Bieber still has the kind of profession worth he contended the beginning of the season, that will certainly aid. Otherwise, things can be extra tough. Whatever is bordered by enigma even what the expectation gets on payroll. It helps that the training team is officially established and the front office can focus entirely on the strategy for 2024 roster building and construction. And the Wintertime Meetings are a wonderful location to begin putting that plan right into practice.